Social media has become a public forum for legal education, professional networking and debate about justice. Nigerian lawyers use it to explain judgments, discuss legislation and contribute to national conversations. These activities can improve public understanding of the law, but they also raise questions about confidentiality, publicity and professional responsibility.
The platform may be informal; the lawyer’s obligations remain professional. The Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners 2023, effective from 1 January 2024, provide the starting point. Some duties apply regardless of the medium used. Other provisions refer to newspapers, radio and television, requiring careful interpretation when applied to contemporary digital platforms.
Professional visibility and attracting clients
Rule 39 does not impose an absolute prohibition on advertising. It permits fair and proper promotion, but that permission is expressly subject to the restrictions in paragraphs (2) and (3). A post does not become compliant simply because its statements are factually accurate.
The restrictions include misleading promotion, promotional comparisons with other practitioners or professionals, statements about the quality or success of a lawyer’s practice, and excessively frequent or obstructive advertising. The Rule also prohibits specified methods of directly or indirectly soliciting professional employment.
For social media users, the practical question is what the communication does as a whole. A professional introduction, an educational discussion and a post designed to secure instructions from people involved in a particular dispute may require different assessments. Claims of guaranteed outcomes or exceptional success deserve particular scrutiny.
Labelling a post “legal education” does not settle its character. Its wording, imagery, audience and invitation to act remain relevant.
Public legal education and individual advice
Rules 42 and 46 recognise legal writing and public explanation of the law. Rule 46(1), however, also restricts accepting employment from the relevant publication or programme to advise enquirers about their individual rights. Its application to particular online arrangements requires interpretation.
As prudent professional practice, lawyers should distinguish general explanations from advice based on an individual’s circumstances. A short comment may omit facts essential to a reliable answer, including dates, documents and jurisdiction.
A disclaimer can explain the intended scope of a post, but it cannot change the substance of an interaction. Followers should not be encouraged to disclose confidential information in public comment threads.
Client confidentiality and online disclosure
Rule 19 protects client communications, confidences and secrets, subject to specified exceptions. These include consent after full disclosure and certain disclosures authorised by law or necessary for defined purposes. It also requires reasonable care to prevent disclosure or misuse by employees, associates and others whose services the lawyer uses.
The ethical inquiry is broader than whether a communication would be privileged evidence in court. A screenshot, client testimonial, photograph or account of a professional encounter may disclose information entrusted to the lawyer.
Removing a name may be insufficient. Dates, locations, unusual facts and previous posts can make a client identifiable. Documents visible in the background of a photograph may reveal information unintentionally.
Where consent is relied upon, the client should understand the proposed disclosure. Consent to disclosure does not authorise conduct prohibited by another applicable rule. Carefully constructed hypothetical examples often provide a better basis for public education.
Pending proceedings and public commentary
Rule 33 applies to lawyers and firms engaged in or associated with the relevant proceedings. Where litigation is anticipated or pending, it prohibits extrajudicial statements calculated to prejudice or interfere with a fair trial, or reasonably capable of doing so. The provision also addresses interference with judgment or sentence.
The lawyer’s connection to the proceedings and the potential effect of the statement matter. The Rule should not be presented as a blanket prohibition on discussing every pending case.
Nevertheless, declarations of guilt, attacks on witnesses or publication of disputed material may create serious concerns. Explaining a procedural development is different from using a livestream to argue contested facts before their determination. A client’s desire for publicity does not displace the lawyer’s independent obligations.
Courts, judges and fellow practitioners
Rule 31 requires lawyers to treat courts with respect, dignity and honour. Where there are proper grounds for complaint against a judicial officer, it directs the lawyer to the appropriate authorities.
Reasoned criticism of a judgment, an allegation against a judge and a formal disciplinary complaint are different activities. Lawyers can contribute valuable analysis by identifying weaknesses in legal reasoning or proposing reform. Allegations of personal wrongdoing require particular care concerning evidence, accuracy and the distinction between fact and opinion.
Professional responsibilities also govern dealings with colleagues. Rule 26 requires respect, fairness, consideration and dignity, while Rule 27 requires good faith and fairness. Hostility between clients should not determine practitioners’ conduct towards one another.
These duties support robust disagreement without personal humiliation or deliberate misrepresentation. They do not require silence about wrongdoing; concerns should be raised accurately and fairly.
Photographs, wigs and gowns
Two separate provisions deserve attention. Rule 45(2)(a) restricts wearing a barrister’s or Senior Advocate’s robe outside court unless directed or permitted by the General Council of the Bar. Rule 46(2)(c) separately prohibits taking steps to procure publication of a lawyer’s photograph, as a lawyer, in the press or a periodical.
On a literal interpretation, putting on the robe specifically to record content outside court engages Rule 45 unless applicable permission exists. Whether a particular digital publication falls within Rule 46’s terminology requires interpretation.
Wearing robes and subsequently publishing their image are distinct acts, but that distinction does not itself establish permission. The occasion, any applicable direction, the purpose of publication and the publicity restrictions must be considered. A photograph alone may not establish all those facts.
Accountability and fair assessment
Rule 1 requires high professional standards and prohibits conduct unbecoming of a legal practitioner. Rule 74 provides that contraventions of Chapter 1 constitute professional misconduct attracting punishment under the Legal Practitioners Act. It also requires lawyers to report known breaches to the appropriate authorities.
An online accusation, a disciplinary complaint and a determination of misconduct are nevertheless different things. Public controversy does not establish a breach, and a complaint does not establish its truth.
Lawyers can make valuable contributions to public discussion while observing their professional obligations. Any allegation of misconduct should identify the applicable rule and establish the relevant facts through the appropriate process.
Legal basis
Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners 2023, SI No 32, Federal Republic of Nigeria Official Gazette, No 103, vol 110, 6 June 2023, supplement B725–B771, particularly Rules 1, 19, 26, 27, 31, 33, 39, 42, 45, 46 and 74.
Note: This commentary examines selected professional conduct provisions. Their application to particular social media activities depends on the facts, relevant regulatory directions and applicable judicial interpretation. It provides general legal information.
Loading reader responses…